How to Hire the Best UGC Creators for Your Brand

Colby Flood
Creative Strategy

Are UGC Services Important for Marketing Campaigns?

Engaging and authentic user-generated content (UGC) is invaluable for brands looking to enhance their online presence and connect with their audience. Increasingly, UGC is a cornerstone of most campaign strategies, making it essential to hire the right creators.

What’s the Difference Between UGC Creators, Influencers, and Affiliates?

The first step is understanding whether you should work with an affiliate, an influencer, or a UGC creator. Each type of collaborator serves a unique purpose in digital marketing:

  • Affiliates focus on direct transactions, earning commissions by generating sales or leads through specific links.
  • Influencers are chosen for their significant online followings and audience niche. They are typically compensated with a flat fee to enhance brand visibility and engagement, regardless of direct sales outcomes.
  • UGC creators share their genuine experiences with products, contributing to a brand’s authenticity and peer-driven trust. In many cases, UGC agencies handle content creation and campaign management for brands. 

Authenticity is one of the most important aspects of UGC content. Finding the right UGC creators requires understanding how to get them to create content that aligns with your brand’s goals while maintaining their own authentic voice. Choosing the right creators and briefing them effectively can significantly affect your brand’s perception and marketing success.

Whether you manage UGC creators in-house, hire a UGC agency, or use an online creator platform, each approach has advantages and drawbacks. After working with a wide range of clients, I’ve put together an in-depth guide to help you navigate your options for hiring UGC creators.

Managing UGC Creators In-House

Pros:

  • Direct Control and Oversight: Managing UGC creators in-house ensures the content aligns perfectly with your brand’s message and campaign goals. Using a strong UGC brief template can help maintain consistency.
  • Relationships: Building long-term relationships with in-house creators fosters a deep understanding of your brand, often resulting in more integrated and authentic content.
  • Cost Management: Managing UGC creators in-house can be more budget-friendly, especially for brands requiring continuous content production, as it eliminates agency fees and platform commissions.

Cons:

  • Time and Effort: This approach requires significant internal resources, including staff time for creative strategy, briefing, contracts, and management.
  • Limited Reach and Diversity: In-house teams may lack the network that agencies or platforms provide, potentially limiting the diversity of your content.
  • Performance Risk: Without external expertise, there might be a longer learning curve in finding the right creators and UGC styles that deliver positive results.

Using a UGC Services Platform

Pros:

  • Wide Range of UGC Creators: Platforms like Upwork or Fiverr provide access to thousands of UGC creators globally, offering diverse skill sets and niche expertise.
  • Streamlined Processes: These platforms include built-in messaging, project management tools, and payment processing to simplify workflows.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Platforms often feature competitive pricing, which is ideal for brands needing to produce content at scale.

Cons:

  • Quality Concerns: The quality of UGC content can vary widely. It’s crucial to review portfolios and read reviews carefully, which requires some upfront work from your team.
  • Lack of Control: Automated processes can sometimes result in content that doesn’t fully align with your vision. It may come off as a bit cold or generic. 
  • Transactional Relationships: Limited personal interaction can lead to content that feels less connected to your brand’s values–you may end up working with creators who don’t represent your brand in the way you’d originally hoped. 

The Benefits of Hiring a UGC Agency

UGC agencies, like Brighter Click, specialize in user-generated content and have deep expertise in social media platforms and effective content strategies. Here are some of the key benefits:

  • Strategic UGC Expertise: Agencies match brands with UGC creators who resonate with their target audience and specialize in content that maximizes engagement and conversions.
  • Efficient Scaling: Agencies manage logistics for multiple campaigns simultaneously, ensuring timely, high-quality content. 
  • Rigorous Vetting: Agencies conduct detailed reviews of creators’ past work, audience engagement metrics, and reliability to ensure top-notch results.
  • End-to-end Management: From creator outreach to final content approval, agencies handle it all, freeing up internal resources. Our team takes care of everything from finding creators and handling contracts to shipping products, collecting assets, and optimizing campaigns.
  • Data Leads The Way: Our team collects and analyzes a wide range of UGC data, from thumb stop and conversion rates to ROAS and CPL. We use that data to continuously improve our client’s ads, creating new iterations and improving our messaging. 
  • Comprehensive UGC Services: Agencies offer a wide array of UGC services, including strategy development, content creation, and performance analysis, ensuring your campaigns are optimized from start to finish.

A UGC agency can be an invaluable partner when campaigns need to scale quickly. Plus, considering ROI, working with an agency is often the most affordable option. 

UGC Examples From Brighter Click

Gelato - Ellen

Ua Body - RAIN - Angela

Eume - Niles

1NW - Momcozy - Nicole

RocketFire

Opencare - Rachel

BROWSE OUR PORTFOLIO

Find The Right Creators to Bring Your Brand Vision to Life.

Schedule a free session with our team to receive:

  • A curated list of UGC creators tailored to your brand and audience.
  • Expert recommendations on content styles that connect with your customers.
  • Clear insights into project costs and timelines.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Submit
Awesome, you subscribed!
Error! Please try again.
Discover how Brighter Click can make your UGC strategy a success.
Schedule a free session with our team to receive:
Thank you! We will review your submission and respond to you shortly!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Please refresh and try again.
Discover how Brighter Click can make your UGC strategy a success.
Schedule a free session with our team to receive:
Thank you! We will review your submission and respond to you shortly!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Please refresh and try again.

Subscribe to Our Marketing Newsletter

Stay up to date with marketing trends and strategies. Our weekly newsletter shares insights from marketing thought leaders, updates with marketing AI tools, access to marketing templates, and much more!

Thank you! We will review your submission and respond to you shortly!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Please refresh and try again.