For any digital marketing agency, tracking ad creative performance is crucial to delivering strong results for clients. At Brighter Click, we rely on structured naming conventions and strategic metrics tracking to ensure every campaign is effectively optimized. Our processes weren’t built overnight––they’ve been optimized through years of working with a broad range of clients, each with unique needs, consistently improving and diversifying our internal data tracking and reporting. 

Here’s a closer look at our creative tracking system, the metrics we prioritize, and how we use this data to inform our decisions on ad testing and optimization.

‍

Naming Conventions and the Creative Tracking Sheet

Managing creative assets for multiple clients requires a robust system to quickly and accurately track performance. This is where naming conventions come in. Having a clear, consistent way of labeling each creative asset in the Supermetrics (SM) Creative Tracking Sheet allows us to get instant insights into ad performance.

Our naming conventions are designed to identify key characteristics of each ad, such as:

• Ad Format: Whether it’s a static image, carousel, or video.
• Creative Theme: The concept or style used in the creative, such as “Us vs. Them,” “Press Article,” or “Benefit Callout.”
• Target Audience: The specific audience segment the creative is aimed at.
• Date and Testing Phase: The month, quarter, or specific test cycle the ad belongs to.

Using this approach makes it easy to see at a glance how specific types of creative perform, allowing us to dive into the details without needing to rely on platform analytics alone.

‍

What Key Metrics Should You Track for Performance Insights?

When it comes to ad performance, not every metric matters equally. At Brighter Click, we prioritize a combination of soft metrics and conversion-focused metrics that provide insight into what’s working and what isn’t.

The soft metrics we typically focus on include:

• Hook Rate: Measures the percentage of users who stay past the first few seconds of a video. A strong hook rate suggests that the opening is engaging and aligned with audience expectations.
• Hold Rate: Indicates how long viewers stay engaged with the ad content. This metric is valuable for understanding if the main body of the creative maintains attention.
• Click-Through Rate (CTR) - All: A general measure of how many users interacted with the ad. High CTR usually shows that the ad’s visual or message resonates broadly with the audience.
• CTR - Link Click: A more specific measure, looking only at users who clicked through to the landing page. This is often a better predictor of the ad’s ability to drive meaningful engagement and traffic.

These metrics provide a holistic view of ad performance, revealing where an ad excels or falls short.

‍

How to Use Metrics to Guide Creative Decisions

Once you’ve collected data on your soft metrics, the next step is to use this information to inform future creative strategy. Here’s how we break down decision-making based on various performance indicators:

• Hook Rate Is Low but Hold Rate Is High: This shows that the ad content is effective once the viewer is engaged but isn’t grabbing attention quickly enough. In this case, we recommend testing a new hook or introducing a more eye-catching opener. Often, even slight adjustments to the first few seconds of a video can make a significant difference.
• Hold Rate Is Low: When viewers are dropping off early, it could mean the content needs more energy or faster pacing. Testing snappier edits, stronger transitions, or a more compelling storyline can improve retention.
• Low CTR (Link Click): A low link click-through rate indicates that while the ad is getting views, it isn’t driving action. This could mean your call-to-action (CTA) lacks clarity or urgency. Adjusting the CTA copy to make it more direct, or creating an incentive (like a limited-time offer), can help increase clicks.
• Conversion Rate (CVR) Is Low: If your CTR is strong but the CVR is low, the issue may lie with the landing page or alignment between the ad and the landing page. We address this by leaning more into behavioral psychology principles, ensuring the ad prepares viewers for the landing page experience. For example, if an ad sets up an expectation of quality, the landing page should immediately convey trustworthiness and quality assurance.

‍

Treat Each Ad as a Unique Funnel

At Brighter Click, we view each ad as its own mini-funnel, breaking down engagement at every step. This approach helps pinpoint exactly where the ad might be underperforming:

• Step 1: Does the ad get impressions?
• Step 2: Are users engaging with the content (e.g., viewing the first three seconds)?
• Step 3: Is the content compelling enough for them to click?

This funnel method allows us to methodically analyze each component and improve the weak spots. Using this process also makes it easy to identify and prioritize quick-win changes—like adding a better CTA or tweaking the hook for greater engagement—versus larger overhauls.

‍

How Creative Themes Can Impact Average Order Value

For e-commerce campaigns, tracking Average Order Value (AOV) alongside other performance metrics can provide valuable insights. For instance, ads that emphasize quality and craftsmanship may increase AOV, as they appeal to consumers willing to pay more for perceived value. Testing themes like “Quality Craftsmanship” versus “Savings & Discounts” can show whether certain themes drive not only higher clicks but also higher-value purchases.

If your CTR ads that focus on quality messaging consistently drive higher AOVs, consider prioritizing these types of creatives when targeting high-spend audiences or pushing premium products. The goal is to understand which messaging frameworks not only increase CTR and conversions but also align with a more profitable customer base.

‍

Managing Creative Fatigue with Data-Driven Iterations

Finally, while “creative fatigue” is a common term in the industry, we’ve found it’s often used as a blanket explanation for declining performance. The reality is that most issues labeled as fatigue result from ad quality or audience fit, rather than repeated exposure.

When you see performance decline, start by examining soft metrics like hook rate, hold rate, and CTR. If these indicate that users are disengaging early, then the creative may need improvement. Rather than scrapping the entire ad, adjust only the underperforming components, like testing a new hook or changing the CTA. This approach allows us to maximize the lifespan of each ad while refining the specific elements that drive results.

‍

Are Your Media Buying and Creative Processes Helping Your Ads?

By establishing consistent naming conventions and tracking key performance metrics, we empower our creative strategists and media buyers to make informed, data-driven decisions that improve ad performance and client satisfaction. 

For any agency, the combination of organized tracking, structured performance analysis, and responsive optimization is essential to creating effective, high-performing campaigns.

‍

Want More Strategies for Success?

Check out The Marketing Mindset Podcast, where I interview industry leaders, marketers, and CEOs from a wide range of industries every week! 

‍

You can also sign up for our Marketing Mindset email newsletter to get all the latest marketing trends, strategies, blogs, and tons of exclusive content sent directly to your inbox!

‍